How Restraining Orders Affect Visitation Rights in San Diego
When a restraining order for domestic violence becomes part of a California family law case, parents will have important questions about what happens next: Does the restrained parent lose custody? Can that parent still see the children? Does the restraining order automatically eliminate visitation?
The answer to these questions depends on the circumstances. A restraining order can significantly affect custody and parenting time, but it does not necessarily terminate all contact between a parent and child. California courts may create restrictions designed to protect the child and the protected parent while determining whether some form of visitation remains appropriate.
Amealia J. Mattis is an experienced San Diego family law attorney. Mattis Law, A.P.C. can help parents address safety concerns, respond to abuse allegations, and pursue parenting orders that reflect the child’s best interests.
How Does a Restraining Order Affect Visitation?
A restraining order does not necessarily end a parent’s visitation rights. In California, a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) is a civil court order intended to protect someone from abuse by a person with whom they have a qualifying close relationship. This may include a current or former spouse, dating partner, domestic partner, or certain close relatives. Abuse may take many forms, including physical, verbal, emotional, psychological, financial, or online abuse.
When the parties share children, a DVRO may include orders addressing child custody and visitation. The person requesting the restraining order can ask the judge to establish custody and parenting-time arrangements as part of the case.
If domestic violence has occurred, the court must consider safety when determining whether and how the restrained parent may spend time with the child. Depending on the circumstances, the judge may order scheduled parenting time, supervised visitation, virtual contact, or no visitation at all.
The restrictions imposed will depend on the facts of the case and what the court determines is appropriate to protect the child and the other parent.
How California Family Code Section 3044 Affects Custody
California Family Code Section 3044 can significantly affect custody when a parent has committed domestic violence within the previous five years. When the law applies, the court must follow a specific process before awarding custody to the parent who committed the abuse.
In many cases subject to Section 3044, the non-abusive parent may receive sole legal and physical custody. However, a finding of domestic violence does not automatically prevent the other parent from having contact with the child. The court may still allow visitation while imposing restrictions designed to address safety concerns.
Legal custody refers to the authority to make important decisions about a child’s education, healthcare, welfare, and other significant matters. Physical custody determines where the child lives. Visitation, also called parenting time, determines when and under what circumstances a parent is allowed to meet with their child.
What Types of Visitation Can a Court Order?
Judges have several options when determining visitation rights in cases involving domestic violence. The appropriate arrangement will depend on the child’s safety and best interests as well as the facts presented to the court.
Possible orders include:
- Scheduled visitation: The court establishes specific dates and times for parenting time rather than leaving the schedule entirely to the parents.
- Supervised visitation: Contact occurs while an approved third party or professional supervisor observes the visit.
- Virtual visitation: A parent and child may communicate through video calls when in-person visits are inappropriate, impractical, or raise safety concerns.
- No visitation: A judge may prohibit visits when contact, including supervised contact, would be physically or emotionally harmful to the child.
How Does Supervised Visitation Work?
Supervised visitation can provide a solution when a judge believes a parent should maintain contact with a child, but unrestricted parenting time would raise safety concerns. A parenting order may address the frequency and length of visits, who supervises them, where they occur, and how the child gets to and from the visit.
During supervised visits, a neutral third person watches and listens while the parent spends time with the child. Courts may use supervision when a case involves domestic violence, alleged child abuse, possible child abduction, substance abuse, mental health concerns, or a parent who needs to rebuild a relationship with the child after an extended separation.
The supervisor may be a professional provider or, when appropriate, a nonprofessional provider. Professional supervisors generally have training and protocols for handling cases involving significant safety concerns, including domestic violence.
Talk to an Experienced San Diego Family Law Attorney
Mattis Law, A.P.C. handles child custody matters, including domestic violence and child custody, supervised visitation, emergency custody, custody modifications, and other high-conflict parenting disputes. We work with families who are facing difficult custody issues by providing informed and sensitive guidance.
Amelia J. Mattis has been named as a Top 10 Family Law Attorney in California by the American Institute of Family Law Attorneys, and Super Lawyers has recognized her as a Rising Star.
If you have questions about restraining orders, visitation rights, or how a DVRO could affect custody and parenting time in San Diego, call (858) 328-4400 to schedule a free consultation with Amelia J. Mattis.
FAQs About Restraining Orders and Visitation Rights in San Diego
Does a restraining order automatically stop a parent from seeing their child?
No. A domestic violence restraining order (DRVO) does not automatically terminate all parent-child contact. Depending on the child’s safety and best interests, the court may allow scheduled, supervised, or virtual visitation or may prohibit visitation when contact would be physically or emotionally harmful to the child.
When will a court order supervised visitation?
A judge may order supervised visitation when safety concerns make unsupervised parenting time inappropriate. This can occur in cases involving domestic violence, child abuse allegations, substance abuse, mental health concerns, abduction risks, or other circumstances that could endanger the child.
Can visitation rights be changed after a domestic violence restraining order is issued?
Yes. Custody and visitation orders associated with a DVRO can potentially be changed through the court. When applicable, a party seeking to modify custody or visitation orders made through a restraining order may need to file Request to Change Child Custody and Visitation Orders (Form DV-305) along with the appropriate request to change or end the DVRO.